Which is best?
In the UK, the majority of schools are co-educational (co-ed) , but there are still a significant number of single sex schools , particularly in the boarding sector. There is a further model called the “diamond formula” in some schools, where boys and girls are taught together until age 10, then separately from 11 to 15 and then in co-educational classrooms again from 16 to 18 in the 6th form.
Historically, a number of the very famous public schools, some of which are over 300 years old, were established as boys’ schools, when it was not considered necessary to educate girls. Schools falling into this category include Winchester, Eton, Harrow and Charterhouse. However in the last century there was a great drive to improve educational opportunities for women and a large number of girls’ boarding schools were established.
The number of girls only schools continued to expand and remain popular, partly because some parents wish to protect their daughters from the rough and tumble and banter of boys, but also because single sex schools provide a uniquely empowering and intellectually stimulating environment for girls where they can develop without distractions from the opposite sex. In recent years there has been a trend for single sex schools to convert to co-ed, even if only at age 16 +, to prepare children for university when they will inevitably have to study and socialise with the opposite sex.
Does this mean co-ed is best? No - it means that all parents should take a decision based on their own beliefs, values and culture and taking into consideration the type of school that will best suit their individual child. In the following sections we examine some of the arguments on both sides, but at the end of the day it will be the parents’ decision.
Single Sex Girls’ Schools
Over the last 10 years the number of pupils educated in girls’ private single sex schools is estimated to have fallen about 10%, as more schools go co-ed , especially in their sixth forms (years 12 and 13). The co-ed argument follows the premise that children should be educated in a mixed environment, which is a reflection of the real world that children will enter when they leave school.
However, do the facts bear this out?
There is no doubt that behaviours tend to differentiate boys from girls and are the result of the way our brains develop. It is not simply that girls are often more interested in playing with dolls and dressing up, while boys are more into sport and rough house games. In girls, the language areas of the brain develop early, while in boys the visual-spatial areas of the brain develop first. Boys and girls both see and hear differently. Boys are more attracted to direction and motion while girls go for textures and colours. It has been suggested that these tendencies result in boys who may struggle with languages and girls who may have little interest in sciences and maths.
It’s quite difficult to cater for these differences in a co-ed environment because it can result in attention deficient, defiant and unmotivated children. Girls simply need the attention they deserve without the distraction of the opposite sex. So, do single sex schools work better? It’s difficult to deny the statistics. At girls only schools, there are 8% more grade As at A Level than for girls in co-ed schools. For GCSEs there are 13% more A*s and As . There is an expectation of success in a girls school and no shame in working hard.
If one examines the top 20 www.best-schools.co.uk A level schools, 16 out of the top 20 are single sex schools – girls only or boys only! If we examine the top 5 international baccalaureate schools, 3 out of the 5 larger cohort schools are girls only. 5 out of 5 smaller cohort schools are girls only. It is also interesting that Cheltenham Ladies College has only been teaching the IB for 3 years and stormed to the top of the table with only their second set of results.
A report from the Institute of Physics (OIP) in 2012 shows that girls from single sex schools are almost 2.5 times more likely to study Physics A level than girls who attend co-ed schools. In single sex schools, girls may not feel pressurised to make subject choices that are stereotypically gender based.
There are around three times as many single sex girls’ schools as boys’. This is undoubtedly down to "demand" because far more parents of girls prefer their daughters to have less distraction from the opposite sex than parents of boys. This is particularly prevalent among certain nationalities or faiths of international parents including Muslims and Catholics. At Education Advisers we have innumerable requests from foreign parents to find girls’ boarding schools with safe and secure campuses away from towns and cities. They prefer their daughters to be removed from areas where there may be unruly behaviour or night time distractions. Yet this rarely crops up as an objection for their sons.
Many parents sending their daughters to boarding school are anxious about them developing relationships with boys and are more comfortable if they are in an all girls environment where any socialising with boys is strictly supervised.
It is sometimes said that girls schools can be “bitchy”, and it is true that girls can form friendship “cliques” which some may feel excluded from. However, there are friendship issues and occasionally bullying in all schools, both single sex and co-ed.
Single Sex Boys’ Schools
The majority of UK private schools use a co-educational model. There are around 20 boys’ single sex boarding schools compared to about 45 girls’ boarding schools and several hundred co-educational boarding schools. Among the boys boarding school list are some extremely well known heritage public schools, including Eton College, Harrow, Winchester, Tonbridge and Dulwich College. There are also a large number of boys independent day schools across the UK some of the more famous being Merchant Taylors, Haberdasher’s Askes, Kings College Wimbledon and Magdalen College, which appear in our top 50.
The co-ed argument follows the premise that children should be educated in a mixed environment, especially as 99% of universities are co-educational and boys and girls need to be properly prepared for life in the “real world” and to learn how to communicate with each other.
However, do the facts bear this out?
As mentioned above, from a young age, boys and girls tend to adopt certain behaviours. Male brains contain large amounts of Y chromosome while female brains have more X chromosome. Chromosomes affect how the brain develops, with girls developing and maturing quicker. The differences are greatest around age 15. Traditionally, boys’ schools tend to operate on the premise that boys enjoy running around, and are highly competitive, so team sports tend to play a major role. Of course this doesn’t apply to every boy, just as there are many girls who love competitive sport. In general, it is perhaps true that most boys tend to develop friendships through sports and the pursuit of common interests, whereas girls tend to bond by talking and sharing experiences.
Boys often take risks and sometimes need to be protected from risks. They like clear hierarchies and teacher authority. Boys often need to be pushed and respond better to clear rules, deadlines and punishments, whereas girls tend to be naturally hardworking and keen to please.
In case these boy traits sound negative, they merely indicate how boys only schools can use effective teaching. Boys not only like physical sports, but like competition and activity brought into the classroom. We were intrigued to find on a visit to a good boys only school in the Midlands, that their 6th form science students were building 3 different sports cars to race.
There has been a reduction in the number of male teachers in co-ed schools., but there are still many male teachers in boys schools and boys do better with role models.
So, do single sex schools help students do better academically? As we have seen, among the top 20 www.best-schools.co.uk A level schools, 16 out of the top 20 are single sex schools – girls only or boys only! If you compare the A Level results of boarders in the top 5 boys only schools with those of the top 5 girl’ schools and the top 5 co-ed schools, the boys results are significantly better. So there must be something about the way boys have been taught in these schools that encourages them to excel academically.
Parent and son relationships are incredibly important as boys mature. We were very impressed by Loughborough Grammar School which arranges Mother & Son evenings at year 7, Father & Son evenings at year 8 plus Father / Son camping expeditions. Loughborough belongs to the International Boys’ School Coalition, designed to bring together effective boys teaching practices from all over the world. It was Loughborough who introduced us to the book "Raising Boys" by Steve Biddulph, an Australian psychologist – a must read for any parent with a son!
The argument for co-education is simply put by most Heads of co-ed schools. We live in a mixed gender society and nearly all UK Universities are mixed sex – so children should grow up together and schools should be capable of getting the best from both girls and boys. A co-ed 6th form environment undoubtedly offers a fun and stimulating experience for both boys and girls. There are many advantages for young people in learning to get on with members of the opposite sex in a structured educational setting, and having boys and girls in the same school is great for drama productions with male and female parts. A co-ed school provides children with the opportunity to learn from each other and how to get on with each other in different contexts.
Parents should also feel reassured that the boarding arrangements are segregated by sex and rules for socialising are strictly enforced at all schools.
Although there are obvious differences between the "typical" boy and the "typical" girl, no child will be 100% suited to a particular learning style. Many girls thrive on competition and many boys love reading. The key is to understand your own child and then decide which type of school will suit them best.
The typical co-ed boarding school tends to be 60% boys and 40% girls, because of the existence of a larger number of girls only schools. Certainly a large proportion of parents support the arguments for co-education and that is how you arrive at a decision - by your own beliefs.
Our job at Education Advisers is to take your brief and find you the right school according to your wishes. We would simply say that there are probably more vacancies available at girls only schools and additionally they are often about 10% cheaper. The choice is yours!
25th September 2017
20th September 2017
19th September 2017